Margaritaville at Lake Lanier Islands is a resort that promises a slice of paradise with its lush beaches, thrilling water slides, and vibrant entertainment. Yet, beneath the surface of this leisure haven lies a history that is anything but idyllic. Last May, a fence was erected to prevent swimming but it inadvertently brings attention to a deeper, darker narrative—the story of Oscarville, the town submerged beneath Lake Lanier.

The Haunted Waters of Lake Lanier

Lake Lanier, a reservoir in northern Georgia, covers 38,000 acres and serves as a popular destination for boating, fishing, and water sports. However, its origins are steeped in controversy and tragedy. Created in the 1950s by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, the lake required the flooding of several communities, including Oscarville, a predominantly Black town with a tumultuous history.

Oscarville was a thriving community until the early 20th century when it became the site of racial violence and forced evictions. In 1912, following accusations against Black residents, white mobs drove out over a thousand Black citizens, effectively erasing the town from the map. Decades later, the creation of Lake Lanier further buried this history under its waters.

Margaritaville: Paradise or Watered-down History?

Margaritaville at Lake Lanier Islands opened its doors with the promise of fun and relaxation. Yet, this modern oasis sits atop a land with unresolved echoes of the past. The resort’s development and subsequent changes, such as the recent fencing to prevent swimming, raise questions about the acknowledgment and respect of the history it covers.

While the fence might be seen as a necessary safety measure, given the lake’s reputation for dangerous conditions and numerous drownings, it also symbolically shuts off access to the submerged stories of Oscarville. The cheerful ambiance of Margaritaville contrasts starkly with the lake’s haunted reputation, where tales of ghostly apparitions and unexplained accidents abound.

A Call for Reflection and Respect

Margaritaville, with its carefree brand of fun, has an opportunity—and perhaps an obligation—to recognize the history upon which it stands. Incorporating elements that honor Oscarville and educate visitors about the lake’s past could transform a place of leisure into one of remembrance and respect.

1. Historical Markers and Memorials: Installing markers or memorials around the resort could provide context about Oscarville’s history and the creation of Lake Lanier. This would educate visitors and honor those who were displaced.
2. Cultural Events and Programs: Hosting events or programs that celebrate the heritage and stories of the original inhabitants can bridge the gap between past and present, turning the resort into a space of cultural appreciation.
3. Partnerships with Historians and Community Leaders: Collaborating with historians, descendants of Oscarville residents, and local community leaders can ensure that the narrative is accurately and respectfully represented.

These memorials and markers would do a bit of justice but when capitalistic ideas are more important than history, money will always come out on top.

Margaritaville at Lake Lanier Islands is more than a resort; it’s a testament to the complex layers of history that define the area. While it offers a retreat from the everyday hustle, it’s crucial to remember that beneath its sunny façade lies a past that, to those that embrace the activities here have or try hard to be forgotten.

However, if the time was taken to acknowledge Oscarville and incorporate its history into the resort’s narrative, Margaritaville could create a more meaningful and respectful experience for all its visitors.